Case Type

Rent Overcharge

Housing Type

Rent Stabilized

Court

Appellate Division, First Department

County

New York County (Manhattan)

L&T / Index / Case / Docket / Clerk's Number

161376/20

Slip Opinion Number

2026 NY Slip Op 05614

Petitioner

Hakim Sutton, et al.

Respondent

76 St. Nicholas Place, LLC

Judge

Moulton, J.P.; Kennedy, J.; Friedman, J.; Michael, J.; Hagler, J.; Goetz, Paul A. (Sup Ct, lower court)

Decision/Order Date

2026-10-01

Posture

Post-Answer Motion by Tenant

Disposition

Motion Granted for Tenant

Winner

Tenant Substantially Won

Synopsis

In a rent overcharge action, the building sold three and a half years after suit began and the former owner asked to swap in the buyer as defendant under CPLR 1021. Supreme Court allowed full substitution, but App Div 1st modifies: the buyer is added as a codefendant under CPLR 1018 and the original owner stays in. Replacing the original owner would let the buyer argue it lacked knowledge of the overcharge to avoid treble damages, a defense the original owner cannot raise, and could shrink the tenants' recovery. Joinder keeps both owners answerable.

Keywords

Substitution/Joinder of Parties; CPLR 1018; New Owner Joined, Not Substituted in Rent Overcharge

Share

COinS