Case Type

Rent Overcharge

Housing Type

Disputed

Court

Appellate Division, First Department

County

New York County (Manhattan)

L&T / Index / Case / Docket / Clerk's Number

650815/22

Slip Opinion Number

2026 NY Slip Op 05611

Petitioner

Joseph Petrolawicz, et al.

Respondent

Ando Realty LLC

Judge

Moulton, J.P.; Kennedy, J.; Friedman, J.; Michael, J.; Hagler, J.; Sattler, Lori S. (Sup Ct, lower court)

Decision/Order Date

2026-10-01

Posture

Post-Answer Motion by Tenant

Disposition

Motion Granted for Tenant

Winner

Tenant Substantially Won

Synopsis

Tenants sued for a declaration that their apartment remains rent stabilized. The owner claimed a post-decontrol first rent of $2,100 in 2011, just over the then deregulation threshold, after a rent-controlled rent near $620. App Div 1st modifies and denies the owner's cross-motion for summary judgment: its managing agent's affidavit did not lay a foundation for the supporting records as business records, so no prima facie case was made and the opposing papers did not matter. Rent history may be examined beyond four years when deregulation is challenged. Denial of the tenants' own motion is otherwise affirmed.

Keywords

Action for Declaration of Rent Stabilized Status & Rent Overcharge; Landlord Failed to Submit Evidence in Admissible Form; Business Records not Authenticated; Summary Judgment Should Have Been Denied

Share

COinS