Case Type

Rent Overcharge

Housing Type

Disputed

Court

Appellate Division, Second Department

County

Queens County (Queens)

L&T / Index / Case / Docket / Clerk's Number

708225/18

Petitioner

Gary Sczesnik, et al.

Respondent

MB Landau, LLC, et al.

Judge

Colleen D. Duffy, J.P., Paul Wooten, Carl J. Landicino, Susan Quirk, JJ

Decision/Order Date

2026-08-26

Posture

Post-Answer Motion by Tenant

Disposition

Other

Winner

Other

Synopsis

In a 2018 class action claiming a J-51 building's owners deregulated units through fraud, App Div 2d holds the tenants did not prove, prima facie, a knowing fraudulent scheme under the totality-of-the-circumstances standard, which applies retroactively; summary judgment on liability and against four affirmative defenses was properly denied. But the owners' counterclaim for attorneys' fees is dismissed. Under the American rule fees require an agreement, statute or court rule, and the lease clauses allowing fees covered only suits to enforce the leases, not tenants' overcharge claims under the Rent Stabilization Law.

Keywords

Attorneys’ Fees for Prevailing Party Denied; No Agreement, Rule, or Statute; Attorneys’ Fees in Lease Only Allowed in Lease Enforcement Actions

Share

COinS