Case Type

HP

Housing Type

Not Stated

Court

Supreme Court, Appellate Term, First Department

County

New York County (Manhattan)

L&T / Index / Case / Docket / Clerk's Number

570713/25

Slip Opinion Number

2026 NY Slip Op 51567(U)

Petitioner

Geraldine Estrada

Respondent

Tower 31 LLC, Garden Apartment Mgmt, NYC Department of Housing Preservation and Development

Judge

James, P.J.; Brigantti, J.; Alpert, J.; Ortiz, Frances A.; Chinea, Daniele (Hous Ct, lower court)

Decision/Order Date

2026-10-01

Posture

Post-Trial Motion by Tenant

Disposition

Other

Winner

Tenant Substantially Won

Synopsis

A tenant's HP harassment case was discontinued without prejudice on condition she pay the owners' legal fees, later set at $54,642.73 after a hearing. App Term 1st upholds discontinuance without prejudice, since the owners showed no substantial prejudice, and agrees CPLR 3217(b) allows conditioning it on fees. But charging fees from the start of the case was an improvident exercise of discretion because the owners caused much of the delay. The award is cut to fees for the discontinuance motion alone, and the case goes back to Civil Court to recalculate.

Keywords

HP Proceeding for Harassment; Landlord’s Fees Limited to Those Incurred in Connection with Landlord’s Opposition to Tenant’s Motion to Discontinue; Landlord Caused Delay in Discontinuing Proceeding

Share

COinS