Case Type

Non-payment

Housing Type

Not Stated

Court

Appellate Division, Fourth Department

County

Cattaraugus County

Slip Opinion Number

2026 NY Slip Op 04722

Petitioner

Gail Hauck

Respondent

James D. Heineman, et al.

Judge

Lindley, J.P.; Bannister, J.; Ogden, J.; DelConte, J.; Hannah, J.; Howden, Moses M. (County Ct, lower court)

Decision/Order Date

2026-07-24

Posture

Post-Trial Motion by Landlord

Disposition

Case Dismissed/discontinued

Winner

Tenant Substantially Won

Synopsis

Upstate case. A town court, after trial, awarded possession, $14,300 and a warrant in a nonpayment proceeding, reasoning the tenants were holdovers once the landlord ended their month-to-month tenancy; County Court affirmed. App Div 4th reverses, vacates the judgment and warrant, and dismisses without prejudice. Nonpayment under RPAPL 711(2) and holdover under 711(1) are separate claims with different defenses and damages. Having conceded she served a termination notice before suing, the landlord's remedy was a holdover; her petition pleaded only unpaid rent and no facts showing termination, so it cannot support holdover relief.

Keywords

Nonpayment Under RPAPL § 711[2] Dismissed Because Trial Court Erroneously Found Tenant Was Holding Over; Different & Distinct Causes of Action Under RPAPL § 711[1] and RPAPL § 711[2

Share

COinS