Case Type

Holdover-Lease Expiration

Housing Type

Disputed

Court

Supreme Court, Appellate Term, First Department

County

New York County (Manhattan)

L&T / Index / Case / Docket / Clerk's Number

570865/24

Slip Opinion Number

2026 NY Slip Op 51632(U)

Petitioner

448-452 West 57 Associates LLC

Respondent

Jeffrey Sposaro, John Doe, Jane Doe

Judge

James, J.P.; Brigantti, J.; Alpert, J.; Stoller, Jack (Hous Ct, lower court)

Decision/Order Date

2026-10-07

Posture

Post-Trial Motion by Landlord

Disposition

Other

Winner

Landlord Substantially Won

Synopsis

App Term 1st reverses dismissal of a lease-expiration holdover and orders a new trial. On stipulated facts, a rent-controlled tenant vacated in 2004 and the next tenant signed a $3,450 free-market lease, but the landlord never registered that tenancy with DHCR and kept filing the unit as rent controlled for years. Civil Court ruled the missing registration meant the landlord could not prove a legal regulated rent over $2,000. Failure to register is notable but not conclusive; regulatory status cannot arise by waiver or estoppel, so the trial court must decide whether the 2004 high-rent deregulation was legitimate.

Keywords

Illegal Deregulation; Failure To Register First Tenant After Rent Controlled Tenant Not Dispositive Of Regulatory Status

Share

COinS