Case Type
Holdover-Other
Housing Type
HDFC
Court
Civil Court of the City of New York
County
Kings County (Brooklyn)
L&T / Index / Case / Docket / Clerk's Number
LT-307370-25/KI
Slip Opinion Number
2026 NY Slip Op 32244(U)
Petitioner
141 MacDonough Street HDFC
Respondent
Tracy Mothershed, John Doe a/k/a Elvis, Jane Smith, Jane Doe
Judge
Arrindell, Travis J.
Decision/Order Date
2026-08-28
Posture
Pre-Answer Motion by Landlord
Disposition
Case Dismissed/discontinued
Winner
Tenant Substantially Won
Synopsis
Dismissal under CPLR 3211(a)(7) of one of three identical holdovers brought by a nonprofit HDFC cooperative, following two other judges' rulings against the same landlord. The HDFC is entwined enough with government that due process requires good cause to evict, so lease expiration alone will not do. The 90-day termination notice said only that the occupant was being terminated for failing to pay rent, with no months or amounts. That conclusory statement does not plead the grounds with the particularity needed to prepare a defense, and a predicate notice cannot be amended.
Keywords
HDFC; Private Housing Finance Law Article XI; HDFC is Entwined with the Government Triggering Constitutional Due Process; Grimmet; Petitioner Must Establish Sufficient Cause for Eviction; Vague Allegations and Lack of Specificity Regarding Failure to Pay Rent Insufficient
Recommended Citation
"141 MacDonough Street HDFC v. Mothershed" (2026). All Decisions. 2552.
https://ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/housing_court_all/2552
