Case Type

Other

Housing Type

Market Rate

Court

Supreme Court of the State of New York

County

Kings County (Brooklyn)

L&T / Index / Case / Docket / Clerk's Number

512113/2022

Slip Opinion Number

31760(U)

Petitioner

5506-40 Linden Blvd Brooklyn LLC, 5507-58 Linden Blvd Brooklyn LLC, 5508-95 Linden Blvd Brooklyn LLC, 5509-130 Martense Street Brooklyn LLC, 5510-345 Lefferts Blvd Brooklyn LLC, 5511-777 St. Marks Avenue Brooklyn LLC

Respondent

Linden 40 LLC, Linden 58 LLC, Linden 95 LLC, Martense 130 LLC, Lefferts Blvd 345 LLC, 777 St. Marks Realty LLC, Edward Lifshitz

Judge

Ruchelsman, Leon

Decision/Order Date

2024-05-21

Posture

Pre-answer Motion by Tenant

Disposition

Motion Granted for Tenants

Winner

Tenants Substantially Won

Synopsis

In a dispute over misrepresented rental amounts in a property sale agreement, the landlord moved to dismiss the tenant's second amended complaint. The court clarified that misrepresentations about rental amounts did not constitute encumbrances, rejecting an expansive interpretation. With no relief available beyond the survival period in the sale agreement, the motion to dismiss was granted, establishing key legal points on encumbrances and res judicata.

Share

COinS