procedural justice, automatic stays, governmental operations, class actions
This note discusses two New York state procedural rules that endanger the poor by giving special treatment to the defendant whom low income plaintiffs most often face in court. First, the New York Civil Practice Law and Rules ("CPLR") allows the government an automatic stay, pending appeal, of all proceedings to enforce an adverse judgment or order. Second, The New York Court of Appeals' "governmental operations" rule creates a presumption against certifying class actions when the challenged action is a governmental operation. The author argues that these rules unfairly limit the ability of poor people to recover against the government in New York state courts, and concludes that the harm caused to poor plaintiffs overshadows any purported benefit of applying these two unique rules.
Jack E. Pace III,
Automatic Stays and Governmental Operations: How New York State Protects the Government from the Poor,
24 Fordham Urb. L.J. 137
Available at: https://ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/ulj/vol24/iss1/4